Myth Busting the Anonymity of DAFs: Reboot

Nearly three years ago, I published a blog post under the same name as this one. 

Since then, the refrain from many in the philanthropic community has not changed: too many fundraisers complaining that DAFs are a pain point and specifically citing donor anonymity as their reason why.  I hear the frustration and I know it comes from a place of good: wanting to steward donors.

But, my soapbox has remained unchanged.  Sure, some donors do use their DAFs to foster anonymous giving.  However, this is certainly not THE reason.  In my opinion, this is one of the biggest myths in DAF giving today.

So, I decided my 2023 blog post needed to be rebooted with a few updates:

Studies show…

To quote Helen Brown’s DAF Assumption Surprises blog post from 2022, “Conservative think tank, The American Enterprise Institute (AEI), was given access to anonymous donation data from 2019 and 2020 from the five largest DAF sponsors: Fidelity Charitable, National Philanthropic Trust, Schwab Charitable, Silicon Valley Community Foundation, and Vanguard Charitable. Like a lot of us, AEI was interested in learning where anonymous DAF donations were actually going. 

“In their white paper Anonymous Giving Through Donor Advised Funds (January 2022) AEI reported that, of the 2,256,033 total grants made in 2020 from donors through the big five sponsors, only 4.3% of those gifts were given anonymously.”

If you are concerned that the AEI study is now several years old, newer data points continue to tell a consistent story.

Fidelity Charitable, one of the largest sponsors in the country, reported in its 2025 Giving Report of the more than 350,000 donors who recommended nearly 2.7 million grants in 2024, only 5% asked that their name and address not be provided to the nonprofits (aka: remain anonymous).

The Donor Advised Fund Research Collaborative’s 2024 National Study on Donor Advised Funds added another important proof point. Based on anonymized account-level data from 111 DAF programs, more than 50,000 accounts, and more than 2.25 million outbound grants, the study found that less than 4% of grant transactions were made anonymously.

And, across the northern border, in Influence, Affluence and Opportunity: Donor-advised Funds in Canada, KCI and the CAGP Foundation found that for DAF donors, anonymity was unimportant relative to other factors in choosing to use DAFs. In fact, almost all donors stated that they are very interested in building relationships with the organizations they support.

Taken together, these studies, using different donors, different methodology, and over a series of years, show that the results are remarkably aligned.  By and large, DAF donors are not unilaterally driven by anonymity.

If so few donors giving through DAFs are actually trying to remain anonymous, what’s the disconnect?  And, why does this myth persist?

To start and quoting Helen’s post again: “one of the underlying issues may be the use of the word “anonymous” here. While the DAF sponsor forwarding along the gift from “The R & C Donor Advised Fund” may not technically consider that donation to be anonymous, for all intents and purposes from the nonprofit’s point of view, it might as well be – unless they happen to know who R & C are.”

This is at the core of the issue: fundraisers want to (and are trying to) steward their donors appropriately.  Most donors want to (and are both expecting and waiting) to be stewarded by the organizations they support.  The lack of proper stewardship is frustrating to both the non-profit and to the donor.  It strains the relationship on both ends.

Cause and Effect

When I first published this post, I had recently wrapped up a call with the leader from a DAF sponsor organization who shared with me that until recently (late 2023), they didn’t have the infrastructure in place to systematically share donor contact information with non-profits.  In essence, when a DAF gift was being fulfilled, it was treated solely as a financial transaction from the sponsor to the receiving non-profit organization. 

This sponsor understood that they had a problem and prioritized the investment needed to update their systems and processes to provide a more holistic experience for both the donor and the non-profit.  Now, end-to-end sharing of donor information is possible for them.

It is unclear how many other sponsor organizations have this same challenge, and it is even more unclear how many of those who do are making the decision to invest in a solution. 

It is also unclear how many sponsor organizations are providing full donor details to nonprofits with their grant distributions, but the nonprofits don’t have the gift processing infrastructure, processes or protocols in place to capture donor data in a way that is meaningful for donor stewardship.

In a more recent example, I am aware of a very large direct-marketing powerhouse nonprofit who uses a caging company to process all offline gifts.  They shared that they have had issues with the caging company not capturing the details on the remit forms that accompany DAF distributions and were not optimistic that they could encourage change.  For the caging company, speed of gift processing was paramount, not slowing down to read through accompanying documentation to then record pertinent information.

Not Just a DAF Problem

Interestingly, this issue of donor identity is not unique to donor advised fund gifts.  If we pull out the lens a bit, we’ve likely all experienced similar challenges with gifts that come through other intermediary entities.

For example, I know I have personally experienced issues where matching gifts funds were not attributed to me as soft credits because the non-profit did not know who was on the other side of the matching gift check that they received from my former employer.

I’ve spoken to colleagues at non-profit organizations that share that they are often similarly flummoxed when a gift of stock arrives from a brokerage firm without an individual donor’s name attached.

And, The Giving Block’s 2023 Annual Report on Crypto Philanthropy notes that there is also a misconception that donors who use The Giving Block to give via cryptocurrency do so to remain anonymous.  In fact, the vast majority (79%) of donors using The Giving Block ask to share their details with the receiving non-profit.

So, what are we to do?

There are likely many solutions to explore but throwing our hands up in frustration is not one of them.

The data should actually give us some optimism: most DAF donors are not trying to be invisible, and many want a relationship with the organizations they support. The opportunity is to make it easier for that relationship to happen.

First, if you work for a non-profit organization, team up with your marketing, advancement services, and gift processing colleagues to ensure that your communications are encouraging donors who give through alternative or intermediary giving vehicles to notify you directly of their gift. You can do this on your website, in your direct marketing appeals, in gift acknowledgement language, and on your donation forms and reply devices. It is likely that many donors assume that you know when their gift arrives, just like I did with my matching gift experience. If they do not realize that you may be having a challenge identifying them, you aren’t giving them a reason to help solve the problem. Remember, most donors give to missions they care about, and they want to be thanked for their support.

Ultimately though, most would agree that this shouldn’t be the donor’s “problem.”  Instead, as an industry we should focus on how to best serve donors.  Here are some recommendations:

Action items for nonprofits

  • Add donor-facing prompts wherever donors make or plan gifts. Use website copy, appeal language, and confirmation pages to ask DAF donors to include their name and contact information with the grant recommendation or to notify your organization directly.
  • Consider installing a DAF widget on your website that helps facilitate the DAF grant and automatically captures donor information for you.
  • Audit your DAF gift workflow. Identify where DAF gifts enter your systems, how they are coded and who reviews them.
  • Develop policies to ensure consistent data entry and a thorough review of any documentation provided by the DAF sponsor.
  • Create a standard stewardship path for DAF donors. Even when the donor is not immediately known, acknowledge the sponsoring organization promptly, track the grant source carefully, and follow up when donor information becomes available.
  • Train fundraisers and gift processors on common DAF sponsor names, account naming conventions, and the difference between truly anonymous gifts and gifts that are merely hard to identify.

And, if you are a DAF sponsor, take a note from the sponsor that I talked to a couple of years ago: prioritize how to make communication and transparency with non-profits more thorough and robust.  Part of your responsibility is to help foster philanthropic giving.  A key component of the philanthropic process is the appropriate stewardship of gifts and relationship building with donors.  The non-profits receiving DAF gifts want this from you.  And, maybe more importantly, your clients – the donors and advisors of the DAFs you are sponsoring – want it too.  You will strengthen your relationship with clients while also enabling a stronger relationship between the nonprofits and their donors.

Image Credit: “Hello, my name is anonymous” by quinn.anya is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0.